I mentioned yesterday in my very maudlin post that I was tired of people buying things instead of doing things. I had several people email me or stop me in the coffee shop and ask me just what, exactly, I meant by that.
To support the troops, we buy yellow magnetic ribbons for our car and feel good. How about going to a VA hospital and volunteering? Well, yes, that would require you to change your life.
So, we buy a $16 t-shirt from American Apparel made with fair trade cotton by inner-city youths. [Rant: so, what is the message of American Apparel, anyway? "Our stuff is made so as not to exploit people, yet we objectify women in our advertising?" Sorry, rant over.] How about try to get by with fewer t-shirts? Or support your local charity thrift store and buy a recycled t-shirt for a buck? Or, heaven forfend, if you are truly worried about inner city youth, how about hooking up with an existing charity and volunteering as a mentor? Yep, another life changer.
We are worried about orphans in Africa, so we buy coffee for $12 a pound that gives kids in Africa food. How about… we study the issue, raise money (maybe by swearing off expensive coffee) and actually get involved? (Drink less expensive coffee? That is it, he has went over the edge!)
We hear that water bottles damage the environment, so we rush out and buy a $20 aluminum designer bottle. What if, instead of that, you bought one bottle of bottled water and actually saved the bottle? Better yet, I bet a friend already has some bottled water at their house they would give you. (But how would people know I am cool?)
So everyone knows that you are into saving the environment, you go out and buy a $25,000 Prius, financing it for five years. What if instead, you actually decided to drive the car you have now, less? What if you decided to try to get by on one car, so you sold one of the two you have in your garage, paid off the other one and used the money you save each month to change the world? (What, and ride the bus? Do you know the dredges of humanity that ride the bus? You want me to sit next to those people?)
I have no problem with organic, with fair trade, with hybrids or helping orphans. My big problem is when people who buy $20 water bottles or organic coffee think they are actually doing something. Here is a news flash: you are not. At best, you are engaging in a holding action, rendering your footprint neutral (there are worse things, I guess). At worst, you are perpetuating the suicide machine that is the American way of life that says we are fulfilled by what we own, what we drive and where we live. Buying things does as much to halt consumerism as promiscuity does to encourage virginity. Instead, use your creativity and intelligence to find ways to reclaim, to recycle, to reuse and to halt the madness.
Change requires change. It just does.